Reunited on 10/27/14
My Siberian Husky was taken in my neighborhood. She was sold the same day on a website and app called OfferUp. Luckily, a good samaritan found her and emailed the information to me, so I contacted the police and got her back after 5 days.
This site didn't directly aid in finding my dog. However, within a few hours of enrolling in their free program they had send her missing flyer to 33 vet hospitals/pet stores/animal shelters in my area which significantly helped cover more ground.
If she had been taken in by a caring neighbor, I am confident she would have been returned at least this quickly. This site was wonderful.